Too Close at Hand: Agency Evaluation of Past Performance

Past performance is an important part of the agency evaluation process—we’ve written about it many times before for a reason. Like other evaluation areas, agencies get a great deal of discretion in evaluating past performance. Perhaps a contractor thinks it has a good past performance record and wants the agency to consider it; perhaps the contractor doesn’t want the agency to ignore a poor past performance record of a competitor. How can a contractor tell when the agency made a reasonable decision not to consider some aspect of past performance? A recent COFC decision showed that the agency cannot ignore adverse past performance in some cases. COFC applied the “too close at hand” doctrine—which says agencies may be obligated to consider information it has during an evaluation, even if the offeror didn’t cite to it. Whether or not an agency’s failure to consider particular information is a violation of this rule or not is a fact-specific inquiry.

Continue reading →

2026 NDAA: DoD CPARS Changes Coming

Both the Senate and House, as part of the draft 2026 National Defense Authorization Acts (NDAA), have proposed nearly identical ideas on overhauling the Department of Defense’s Contractor Performance Assessment Report System (CPARS) processes. While both NDAAs have passed, and therefore require reconciliation in a committee, their ideas are extremely similar and signal a coming change in CPARS processes for defense contractors. One big change is to focus on specific negative performance events using “a standardized scoring mechanism” and to remove reporting on “positive or neutral performance assessments.”

Continue reading →

SBA Final Rule Eases Use of Small Business Joint Venture and Subcontractor Past Performance

SBA has issued a final rule that should help small businesses demonstrate their past performance more easily. Perhaps most importantly, the rule will allow for a small business to receive a written performance record, similar to CPARS, showing its performance as a subcontractor to a large business prime. The new rule will also allow a small business to better utilize its past performance that it carried out as a member of a joint venture.

Continue reading →

Agency Properly Awarded Contract to Company with Nine Negative CPARs

Among some contractors, it’s taken as an article of faith that even a single negative Contractor Performance Assessment Report will effectively preclude the contractor from winning new government work.

While it’s undoubtedly true, in my opinion, that some Contracting Officers place too much emphasis on a single less-than-perfect CPAR, it’s also true that a contractor with multiple negative CPARs can still win government contracts, so long as the government reasonably believes that the contractor can successfully perform the new work. Case in point: a recent GAO bid protest decision upholding an award to a company with nine (count ’em!) recent, relevant and negative CPARs.

Continue reading →

CPARS Challenges: No Appeals Without Contracting Officer Claim

Ask many government contractors, and they’ll tell you that even a single negative report in the Contractor Performance Assessment Reporting System can have a powerful adverse impact on winning future prime contracts.

Given the importance of these performance reports, it’s little wonder that a contractor on the receiving end of a negative CPAR may want to ask a judge to review the matter. But as one recent case demonstrates, a contractor cannot challenge a CPAR with a judge until the contractor has followed the FAR’s claims process.

Continue reading →

FedBizOpps is Almost Gone

There’s a scene in 2016’s War Dogs where the Jonah Hill character explains to his employees that they are going to spend all day every day digging through one website. In the background, extras are seen staring in to the blue and yellow glow of FedBizOpps.gov.

“Oh my,” I exclaimed from my couch to no one in particular. “I use that website every day—it’s terrible.”

Continue reading →

GAO to Agency: Offerors are More than Just a CPARS-Generated Rating Percentage

GAO recently sustained protest to an agency’s FAR Part 13 procurement that relied exclusively on CPARS-generated assessment chart rating percentages to evaluate vendors’ past performance. The agency’s goal was to “maximize competition” by considering all past work, rather than just relevant work.

While there is no FAR Part 13 regulatory prohibition on doing so, GAO found the CPARS charts incomplete and misleading and the evaluation inconsistent with the terms of the solicitation.

Continue reading →