Large Prime Hit For “Consistent Failure” To Meet Subcontracting Goals

A large prime contractor’s “consistent failure” to meet its small business and socioeconomic subcontracting goals on prior projects resulted in a lower past performance score–and led to the prime’s elimination from the competition. In a recent bid protest decision, the GAO held that the agency properly eliminated a prospective prime contractor from the competition in […]

Subcontracting Goals Missed; Incumbent’s Past Performance Score Lowered

A large incumbent contractor was properly assigned a mere “satisfactory confidence” past performance rating because the large business failed to meet its small business subcontracting goals under four of the five contracts it submitted for evaluation. In a recent bid protest decision, the GAO upheld the agency’s assignment of a satisfactory confidence score to the large […]

Large Business’s Unmet Subcontracting Goals Result In “Marginal” Score

A large business was appropriately awarded a “Marginal” score for small business participation based on the large business’s history of failing to meet its small business subcontracting goals. In a recent bid protest decision, the GAO held that the procuring agency properly assigned the large business a low score based on the large business’s history […]

Subcontracting Ambiguity Results in Proposal Downgrade

In a recent case, a federal court held that a procuring agency properly downgraded an offeror’s proposal because the proposal was ambiguous as to how much of the contract work the offeror intended to subcontract. According to the Court, even though the amount to be subcontracted was small in any event, the ambiguity meant that […]

Federal Court Upholds Agency’s 40% Small Business Subcontracting Goal

The United States Court of Federal Claims has denied a challenge to the Transportation Security Administration’s establishment of a 40% small business subcontracting goal–measured by total contract price, not total subcontracting dollars. In Firstline Transportation Security v. The United States, No,. 12-601C (2012), Judge Thomas Wheeler  rejected arguments that the TSA’s 40% small business subcontracting […]

GAO: Small Business Teaming Agreement Must Follow Solicitation Guidelines

As we often tell people, language in a teaming agreement is important for a federal contract. But so is complying with the terms of a solicitation. A recent GAO decision hinged on a very specific portion of the language in a teaming agreement that was required as part of a solicitation. Because the contractor did […]

On Deck for SBA Regulations in 2023: Affiliation and WOSB Rule Changes

SBA, like other agencies, publishes a semiannual Regulatory Agenda to provide an update on the various rules it has coming up as well as a timeline for when they will be published or become final. While SBA doesn’t have to meet these timeframes, it’s always good to check in on what SBA has been working on when […]