Back to Basics: NAICS Code Appeals

One of the most important pieces of information for a small business government contractor is the NAICS code. For a simple six-digit number, it can be determinative of a wide range of important matters for contractors and the procurements they pursue—size standards, applicable limitations on subcontracting, and more. As we’ve written about many times, selection of a NAICS code is so important that a misclassification will support a NAICS code appeal. While such an appeal is less well known than size or status protests, it can be quite useful for prospective bidders. In addition, with the proposed changes to small business size standards, this kind of appeal may become highly relevant in the near future. As such, today we go back to the basics on the NAICS code appeal: what they are and how they work.

What is a NAICS code?

First things first, a North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) code is a six-digit code assigned to one of over a thousand different industries (proposed changes would reduce the numbers of codes applicable to federal contracting to 338 separate size standards). The codes are assigned by the U.S. Census Bureau “for the purpose of collecting, analyzing, and publishing statistical data related to the U.S. business economy.” Note, however, the “NA-” in NAICS; industries in Canada and Mexico use them too. The NAICS manual is a useful reference that, among other things, explains how the codes are assigned.

The NAICS system and its codes are used for all sorts of government things; where we’re concerned is how SBA uses them for regulating small business federal contracts. SBA, in its Table of Size Standards, assigns a different size standard to each code based on either a dollar amount in receipts or a total number of employees.

For example, NAICS code 236210, “Industrial Building Construction,” carries a receipts-based size standard of $45 million. NAICS code 333120, “Construction Machinery Manufacturing,” on the other hand, carries an employee-based size standard of 1,250. So if an agency assigns 236210 to a solicitation, only contractors whose average receipts are under $45 million per year can bid on the procurement. Similarly, if a solicitation is assigned 333120, only contractors with fewer than 1,250 employees can bid on it.

Contracting officers are required to assign a single NAICS code per solicitation—and must select the single code which best describes the principal purpose of the product or service sought, according to 13 C.F.R. 121.402(b). Because some solicitations involve a mix of goods, services, and other areas, that selection allows COs to have a fair amount of discretion. However, that discretion is not unlimited. COs have to make a reasonable selection based on the NAICS manual descriptions, the overall character of the procurement, the intended function of the end item, and the relative value of the various performance components.

Challenging a NAICS Code

SBA’s regulation on NAICS code appeals are quite broad: any person adversely affected by a NAICS code designation may appeal a code’s designation. However, they do require a relatively quick turnaround, as these appeals must be filed within 10 calendar days after the issuance of the solicitation (or an amendment affecting the NAICS code). Other forms of protests regarding solicitation defects usually are due by the proposal submission due date, so this is an area where NAICS code appeals differ from protests of solicitation terms.

OHA evaluates NAICS code appeals by comparing the procurement’s statement of work with the code definitions in the NAICS manual. As the action being reviewed is the decision-making process of the CO, the key to success in a NAICS code appeal is showing that the assigned code clearly doesn’t match what the agency is procuring. Successful protestors often compare the solicitation’s scope of work with other past examples of similar work to demonstrate that the majority of work often is (and therefore should be) procured under a different code.

Because the NAICS code is so important to the procurement, OHA processes these appeals before other matters and gets decisions issued as soon as possible. On average, OHA will deliver a decision in a NAICS code appeal between 18 and 30 days.

Bottom Line

NAICS code appeals are less common than other forms of procurement challenges, but have an above-average success rate. Looking at appeals decided on the merit (i.e., not withdrawn or determined by factors other than the arguments made), about 45% of these appeals are granted. As such, they offer a powerful tool to any contractor adversely affected by a procurement’s code designation. As the timeline for filing such an appeal is very short, with the potential for a very good payoff, consider reaching out to government contracting personnel if you believe a NAICS code was assigned in error.

Questions about this post or need legal assistance? Email us.

Looking for the latest government contracting legal news? Sign up for our free monthly newsletter, and follow us on LinkedIn, Twitter and Facebook.