Interested? Maybe. ODRA Says that an Awardee Can Be Interested Party for a Protest.

For the most part, not everyone can protest an agency’s award decision. As we’ve discussed before, GAO, for example, requires that a protester be an “interested party” if they wish to protest an award. In such cases, a protester is an “interested party” where it is “an actual or prospective offeror whose direct economic interests would be affected by the award of a contract or the failure to award a contract.” 4 C.F.R. § 21.0(a)(1). Now, in general, one who has been awarded a contract cannot protest other awardees, something we explored a good few years ago. But, recently, the FAA’s Office of Dispute Resolution for Acquisition (ODRA) noted that, at least for ODRA, the rule isn’t quite the same, although in the decision in question it nonetheless found the protester to not be an interested party. We explore that decision here.

In Protest of Science Applications International Corp, 25-ODRA-00986 (Sept. 15, 2026), Science Applications International Corp. (SAIC) was awarded an unrestricted IDIQ contract under a solicitation along with a company named Noblis, Inc. (Noblis). SAIC filed a protest that this award to Noblis was unreasonable and contradicted by the record as the FAA had initially recommended award of just a single unrestricted contract. The company further asserted that the FAA’s justification for making a second award was also unreasonable and contradicted by the record.

The FAA doesn’t operate by the FAR, unlike most federal agencies. But many of its rules are similar. The interested party requirement for protests is no exception. ODRA, citing to 14 C.F.R. § 17.3, noted that “[u]nder the ODRA procedural regulations, an interested party is ‘one whose direct economic interest has been or would be affected by the award or failure to award an FAA contract.’” As you can see, this is very similar to GAO’s rule. ODRA went on to note that, where the protester isn’t an awardee, this generally means that the protester must show that it is “next in line” for award if its protest were to succeed.

But, ODRA noted, that “next in line” standard isn’t “an inviolable requirement to establish status as an interested party.” For example, it noted that ODRA found in one case that a direct economic interest still existed despite the protester not being necessarily “next in line” as correcting the alleged error would have required either reordering many offerors or simply reopening the competition. Protests of SOFIS-TRG, LLC; 22-ODRA-00902 to – 00906 (June 15, 2022). From this, ODRA noted that the mere fact a protester is an awardee does not mean it can’t be an interested party just because it isn’t “next in line” if its protest is successful.

Indeed, ODRA noted that, where it has agreed with GAO on what makes a protester an interested party, the question primarily comes down to “direct economic interest.” But the definitions are not the same. ODRA’s rule is that an interested party is “one whose direct economic interest has been or would be affected by the award or failure to award an FAA contract.” 14 C.F.R. § 17.3 (emphasis added). In contrast, GAO’s definition from 4 C.F.R. § 21.0(a)(1) is that an interested party is “an actual or prospective offeror whose direct economic interests would be affected by the award of a contract or the failure to award a contract.” (emphasis added). The issue is that GAO has concluded that an awardee cannot be “an actual or prospective offeror” with regards to the contract awarded to the other awardee in such circumstances. Aegis Def. Servs., LLC, B-412755 (Mar. 25, 2016).

GAO’s definition is based on the Competition in Contracting Act, 31 U.S.C. § 3551(2)(A), which also defines an “interested party” as “an actual or prospective bidder or offeror whose direct economic interest would be affected by the award of the contract or by failure to award the contract.” As the Court of Federal Claims has commented: “On the other hand, in a multiple award procurement where an offeror receives the very contract it sought — i.e., the only contract for which it submitted a proposal — that offeror cannot be considered an ‘actual offeror’ with respect to the other contract awards it did not seek (and, indeed, could not have sought).” Aero Spray, Inc. v. United States, 156 Fed. Cl. 548, 566 (2021).

Some may think that this reading, which has been apparently adopted by various courts and tribunals over the years, is a peculiar one. It is unclear how an awardee loses its status as an offeror for a given award simply because it receives an award. Although on the other hand it has a certain logic that one can no longer fight for what one already has. It is even more unclear how an awardee somehow is not an offeror for an award made to the other awardee on the grounds that it wasn’t “seeking” the other award. It seems to us a strange, unnecessary position when, for the most part, a court can dispose of the awardee’s protest on the basis the awardee lacks a direct economic interest in the award, which is the other requirement to be an interested party.

In any case, ODRA, not having to abide by the same language as GAO, noted that it applies this simpler approach, observing: “In contrast, under the ODRA’s ‘interested party’ definition, an awardee, by definition, can be ‘one whose direct economic interest has been … affected by the award … [of] an FAA. contract,’ even if not their own.” Looking at the question of economic interest, then, ODRA noted SAIC’s claim was essentially that it had an economic interest in all of the task orders that might be issued under the IDIQ. ODRA rejected SAIC’s claim, quoting that “due to the nature of IDIQ contracts, awardees have no legally cognizable expectation of receiving future task orders but only a ‘guaranteed a [sic] minimum quantity of orders and a fair opportunity to compete for future task orders.’”

Why does this matter for you? For one, if you do FAA work, the fact you’re an awardee doesn’t necessarily prohibit you from protesting! But, otherwise, the big thing is that there are many moving parts when it comes to bringing a protest, and going at it alone is generally inadvisable. As shown above, being an awardee generally means your protest would get dismissed, but it is not automatically the case (even Aero Spray acknowledged exceptions to its own rule). Further, even if you’re familiar with, say, GAO, that doesn’t mean the rules that apply to it also apply to COFC or ODRA. Bottom line: If you’re considering a protest, it is a great risk to do so without counsel.

Questions about this post or need legal assistance? Email us.

Looking for the latest government contracting legal news? Sign up for our free monthly newsletter, and follow us on LinkedIn, Twitter and Facebook.